Skip to main content

Feedback is one of the most important leadership tools. It significantly influences employee motivation, satisfaction, and performance.

 

However, research shows something surprising: In around 30% of cases, feedback actually hurts performance. What goes wrong?

Why Feedback Can Slow Down Employee Performance

Traditional feedback has a fundamental flaw: it looks backward. It focuses on past events and mistakes. Leaders often concentrate on what employees should improve.

While this might motivate some people to try harder, it creates unwanted side effects. Deficits get more attention than strengths, which can threaten self-worth, especially when careers are at stake. Employees become demotivated when they don’t understand or disagree with the assessment. Vague criticism without specific examples causes the most damage.

The Better Alternative: Feedforward

Feedforward completely flips the approach. Instead of analyzing the past, it focuses on future possibilities. Rather than dissecting mistakes, it builds concrete action plans for upcoming challenges.

The Science Behind It

Future-oriented, strength-based conversations do something powerful: they activate the brain’s reward system. This boost enhances creativity, improves problem-solving ability, and increases willingness to change.

At its core is a structured conversation called the Feedforward Interview. Through a guided dialogue, managers identify employee strengths and collaboratively develop specific actions that foster personal growth and goal achievement.

Rather than evaluating performance, the manager becomes a conversation partner — asking thoughtful questions, listening actively, and supporting employees to reflect on their most successful work experiences, thereby unlocking future potential.

The 3 Steps of the Feedforward Interview

1

Identifying Positive Work Experiences

Start by discussing both positive and negative work experiences. Then ask the employee to describe a situation where they succeeded. This simple step triggers positive emotions that strengthen self-confidence and expand one’s sense of what’s possible.

 

Try this question: “Tell me about a project where you were very proud of the result. What went particularly well?”

2

Discover Strengths

Analyze that success story together. Explore what specific strengths contributed to the win, what abilities they used, and how they can apply these strengths to future challenges.

 

Try this question: „Regarding your successful project, you mentioned that you proceeded very systematically. How can you use this strength in other tasks as well?”

3

Shape The Future

Based on their strengths, develop new goals, clear implementation strategies, and specific growth opportunities. Focus on concrete solutions for future challenges.

 

Instead of saying this: “You always miss deadlines.”

Try this approach: So that you don’t exceed deadlines in the future, you could break tasks down into smaller steps and then set realistic deadlines. How about creating a detailed schedule for your next project?”

Using Feedforward In Professional Daily Life

Feedforward isn’t just for annual reviews. You can also use it for new assignments by setting learning goals upfront. Apply it in daily collaboration to encourage regular reflection. Deploy it before challenging projects to build confidence.

Try this question: Before an important customer meeting:
“Based on your experience with similar customers, which of your strengths will help you in this meeting? How can you use them strategically?”

The Benefits Of Feedforward

Feedforward focuses on individual strengths and growth opportunities instead of analyzing past mistakes. In conversations with employees or teams, feedforward reveals its true strengths:

Future-oriented and solution-focused:

The Feedforward approach gives employees a clear roadmap for what to do next, not just what went wrong.

Constructive and inspiring:

Feedforward is constructive because it shows a clear path for improvements while emphasizing a person’s strengths and behaviors necessary for success.

Objective and depersonalized:

Non-threatening discussions focus on future possibilities instead of past failures. Plus, the behavior is detached from the respective person and not judged, which reduces defensiveness.

Strength-based and motivating:

When emphasizing strengths and positive experiences, a person’s motivation and engagement increase.

Performance-enhancing:

People are more capable when they know and use their strengths.

Promoting relationships:

The positive nature of the conversation reinforces leader-employee bonds and fosters their relationship.

Experienced appreciation:

Employees feel valued and respected when their perspectives are considered and their strengths are recognized.

More effective than traditional feedback:

Feedforward is more targeted than traditional feedback because it focuses on actionable steps for improvement.

The Bottom Line: Use Both Approaches

Feedforward is a powerful and innovative tool for boosting employee performance and satisfaction. It strategically identifies and leverages individual strengths to create development opportunities.

Nevertheless, traditional feedback still has value for learning from mistakes and identifying improvement areas.

The winning combination starts with feedforward to create a positive, constructive foundation for subsequent feedback and thus reduces possible negative effects.

Both approaches are useful and can promote performance and development based on the situation.

My Tip

Start with one feedforward conversation per week. Gather experience and gradually develop your own feedforward routine.

What’s your experience? How do you plan to use feedforward in your leadership practice? I would love to hear your thoughts; I’m really excited.

 

Do you want to use your team’s strengths? Schedule your free call now.

Schedule A Free Call Now

Get More

The Effects of Feedback:

Kluger, Avraham & DeNisi, Angelo. (1996). The Effects of Feedback Interventions on Performance: A Historical Review, a Meta-Analysis, and a Preliminary Feedback Intervention Theory. Psychological Bulletin. 119. 254-284. 10.1037/0033-2909.119.2.254.

The Feedforward Interview:

Marie-Hélène Budworth, Gary P. Latham (2025). The feedforward interview: An innovative approach to performance appraisal.

Feedforward Video:

Marshall Goldsmith: Coaching For Behavioral Change

Andrea Seekatz

I am a Professional Certified Coach (ICF) and psychologist. From strengths analysis to employee retention: strenghts-focused leadership coaching.

Leave a Reply

Cookie Consent with Real Cookie Banner